Blog
Time Management: Why Your System Is Probably Making You Less Productive
Productivity gurus hate me for saying this, but most time management advice is absolute rubbish designed to sell planners and apps.
After seventeen years of running training workshops across Melbourne and Perth, I've watched countless professionals torture themselves with colour-coded calendars and minute-by-minute schedules that would make a Swiss train conductor weep with joy. The reality? About 78% of people who implement these "foolproof" systems abandon them within six weeks. I know because I used to be one of those statistics.
The Great Time Management Lie
Here's what nobody tells you: perfect time management doesn't exist. Never has, never will.
The entire industry is built on the premise that if you just find the right system, download the perfect app, or follow the ultimate methodology, you'll transform into a productivity machine. What a load of absolute nonsense. I've seen senior executives spend more time managing their time management system than actually getting work done.
The problem isn't your system. It's your expectations.
I learned this the hard way during my early consulting days when I tried to implement every productivity hack known to humanity. The Pomodoro Technique. Getting Things Done. Time blocking. Eisenhower matrices. The lot. By 2018, I was spending two hours each morning just organising my day. Brilliant strategy, that one.
What Actually Works (And What Doesn't)
Let me share something controversial: the best time managers I know are actually quite disorganised by traditional standards.
Take Sarah, a project manager at a major Melbourne construction firm. Her desk looks like a paper bomb exploded. Her calendar has gaps you could drive a truck through. Yet she consistently delivers projects ahead of schedule while her perfectly organised colleagues struggle to meet basic deadlines.
Why? Because Sarah understands something most people miss entirely.
Time management isn't about controlling time – it's about understanding your own patterns and working with them instead of against them. Revolutionary concept, I know.
The Australian Approach to Getting Things Done
We Australians have always had a different relationship with time compared to our American cousins. While they're optimising their morning routines and biohacking their circadian rhythms, we're having a proper coffee and figuring out what actually needs doing today.
This cultural difference isn't a weakness. It's our secret weapon.
The most effective leadership skills for supervisors I've observed come from people who prioritise relationships over rigid schedules. They understand that sometimes the most productive thing you can do is have an unplanned conversation in the kitchen.
But here's where it gets interesting – and where most time management advice completely misses the mark.
The Three Things That Actually Matter
Forget everything you've been told about time management. Focus on these three principles instead:
1. Energy Management Beats Time Management
Your brain doesn't function at peak capacity for eight straight hours. Shocking revelation, I know. Yet we persist with this industrial-age notion that all hours are created equal.
I do my best analytical work between 6am and 10am. My creative thinking peaks around 2pm. By 4pm, I'm only good for emails and administrative tasks. Fighting this natural rhythm is like swimming upstream – possible, but unnecessarily exhausting.
2. Saying No Is More Important Than Saying Yes
This one makes people uncomfortable, especially in Australian workplace culture where being helpful is practically a national identity. But every yes to one thing is a no to something else. Basic mathematics, really.
The most successful people I work with have become masters at polite refusal. They've learned that being selective about commitments isn't selfish – it's strategic.
3. Perfect Systems Create Imperfect Results
This brings us back to my earlier point about over-optimisation. The moment you create a system that requires perfect execution, you've guaranteed its failure. Humans aren't machines. We have bad days, unexpected emergencies, and moments of complete brain fog.
Build flexibility into everything you do. Plan for disruptions. Expect the unexpected.
The Mobile Phone Menace
Speaking of disruptions, let's talk about the elephant in the room – your smartphone. That little device is probably destroying more productivity than all other distractions combined.
Research from the University of Sydney (I think it was 2019, though I might be misremembering) found that the average knowledge worker checks their phone 47 times per day. Every interruption costs approximately 23 minutes to fully refocus.
Do the maths. That's nearly eighteen hours of lost focus time daily. No wonder everyone feels like they're drowning.
Yet somehow, productivity experts keep recommending apps to solve productivity problems. It's like suggesting cigarettes to cure lung cancer.
What I Got Wrong (And What You Probably Are Too)
For years, I preached the gospel of detailed planning. Weekly reviews. Daily priorities. Monthly goal setting. The whole productivity pyramid.
Then I noticed something peculiar. My most successful clients were the ones who ignored about half my advice.
They didn't meticulously plan every hour. They didn't conduct elaborate weekly reviews. They certainly didn't obsess over goal alignment matrices. Instead, they focused on doing fewer things with greater attention.
Mind-blowing stuff, really.
This revelation led me to completely restructure how I approach workplace training. Instead of teaching people to manage time, I started teaching them to manage attention and energy.
The Reality Check Most People Need
Here's something nobody wants to hear: if you need a complex system to manage your time, you're probably doing too much.
Complexity is often a symptom of poor boundaries rather than poor planning. Before you download another productivity app or buy another planner, ask yourself this question: what would happen if you just did 20% less?
Most people panic at this suggestion. "But everything is important!" they protest. "I can't just stop doing things!"
Actually, you can. And you should.
The Pareto Principle applies beautifully to productivity. Twenty percent of your activities generate eighty percent of your results. The trick is identifying which twenty percent and having the courage to eliminate the rest.
Building Your Actually Useful System
If you're still with me (and haven't dismissed this as heretical productivity blasphemy), here's how to build a time management approach that actually works:
Start with your energy patterns. Track when you feel most alert, creative, and focused over two weeks. Don't try to change anything – just observe.
Then align your most important work with your peak energy periods. Revolutionary, I know.
Next, identify your biggest time drains. For most people, it's meetings, emails, and interruptions. Address these systematically rather than trying to work around them.
Finally, build in buffer time. Lots of it. If you think something will take an hour, block ninety minutes. If your commute is usually thirty minutes, leave forty-five minutes early.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Productivity
Most productivity problems aren't really about time management. They're about decision fatigue, unclear priorities, and poor communication systems.
You don't need another app. You need better boundaries. You don't need a more detailed calendar. You need clearer priorities. You don't need perfect systems. You need sustainable habits.
The most productive people I know use remarkably simple systems. A basic calendar. A simple task list. Clear priorities. That's it.
They succeed not because they've optimised every minute, but because they've optimised their decision-making. They know what matters and they focus on that.
Everything else? It either gets delegated, delayed, or deleted.
Where This Leaves Us
Time management isn't really about managing time at all. It's about managing yourself within the constraints of time you have available.
Stop chasing the perfect system. Start working with your natural patterns. Stop trying to do everything. Start doing the right things.
Your future self will thank you for it. Even if your colour-coded calendar doesn't approve.
Related Resources: